Best Roof Material? A Guide For Florida Homeowners (2025)

If you’re roofing in Florida, metal roofing comes in highly recommended. It stands up to hurricanes, slashes energy bills, and lasts decades longer than shingles. But it’s not the only option, and choosing wrong can cost you. Here’s how to pick the right roof for your Florida home.

Too many Florida homeowners still pick their roofing material like they’re buying a pair of shoes; cheapest price, fastest install and looks good from the street. But that can easily become a nightmare.

That’s not the right way to choose a roof. 

It should be a mindful decision because you’re buying something that’ll protect you for decades to come.

We’ve reroofed hundreds of homes and seen firsthand how the right roof can protect a family and the wrong one can break the bank.

That’s why we’ve prepared this guide to help you get the best roof option for your head. Let’s get into it right away and have a detailed comparison of all the options. 

Quick Comparison: Which Roof Performs Best in Florida?

Here’s a quick breakdown of how each roofing material performs where it counts: Florida’s heat, storms, and insurance landscape.

Florida Roofing Comparison Chart

 

Material	Lifespan (Years)	Hurricane Resistance	Maintenance Level	Insurance Friendly	Av. Cost (FL)
Asphalt Shingles	10–20	Low (100–110 mph)	Moderate	Lowest score	$4.50–$7 / sq ft
Clay Tile	25–50	Good	High	Medium-High	$10–$18 / sq ft
Concrete Tile	30–50	Good	Moderate	Medium	$8–$12 / sq ft
Metal Roof	40–70	Excellent (165+ mph)	Low	High	$10–$16 / sq ft
Composite	40–50+	Excellent (up to 211 mph)	Very Low	Excellent	$12–$18 / sq ft
Silicone/Foam	15–30 (with upkeep)	Moderate to High	Moderate (needs recoating)	Medium-High	$6–$12 / sq ft

 

Now let’s get into a detailed comparison so you have everything you need to make the best decision for yourself.

Comparing Florida’s Most Popular Roofing Materials Head-to-Head

 

Let’s break it down. These are the five most common roofing materials in Florida, what they cost, how they perform, and which ones actually stand up to our brutal weather.

1. Asphalt Shingles 

Average cost: $4.50–$7 / sq ft

Asphalt shingles are the most widely used roofing material in Florida, largely because they’re affordable, readily available, and quick to install. 

But in Florida’s climate, affordability comes at a long-term cost, especially for homeowners who plan to stay put. Between the heat, humidity, and hurricane threats, shingles break down faster than most realize.

Pros – Why Homeowners Still Choose Them:

1. Budget-friendly: Shingles are the lowest-cost option upfront, making them appealing for tight budgets, quick flips, or investment properties.
2. 2. Fast and simple installation: Most shingle roofs can be installed in a day or two, minimizing disruption and labor costs.
3. 3. Easy to repair (in theory): It’s relatively simple to replace a few damaged shingles, if the color and style are still available (which isn’t always the case).

Cons – What Most Homeowners Regret:

1. Short lifespan in Florida: While advertised to last 25–30 years, shingles typically survive just 10–15 years here due to UV exposure, wind, and moisture.
2. Poor storm resistance: Shingles are vulnerable to uplift in winds over 100 mph. During hurricane season, we often see them peeled off in sheets.
3. Heat absorbent: Shingles retain heat, raising attic temps and increasing cooling costs, a major issue in Florida’s subtropical climate.
4. Insurance limitations: Many insurers won’t offer full coverage on shingles past 15 years, especially if there’s no wind mitigation or proper documentation. After a storm, your claim might be denied outright.

If you’re planning to stay in your home, asphalt shingles are rarely the best option. They may save you money today, but you’ll likely pay for it in repairs, replacements, and insurance headaches later.

2. Clay Tiles 

Average cost: $10–$18 / sq ft

Clay tile roofs are iconic in Florida’s coastal architecture. 

You’ll see them lining neighborhoods in Naples, Coral Gables, and other upscale communities for a reason.

But while they’re beautiful, clay tiles come with structural demands and maintenance risks that homeowners need to understand before committing.

Pros – Why Homeowners Love Clay Tile Roofs:

1. Excellent heat deflection: Clay tiles create natural airflow between the roof and the decking, helping reduce attic temperatures and energy use.
2. Visually striking and HOA-friendly: Clay tiles are often required or encouraged in high-end communities. Their curb appeal boosts resale value and architectural integrity.
3. Naturally fire-resistant and storm-rated: When installed properly with the right fasteners and underlayment, clay tile systems can meet wind ratings and offer protection against fire spread.

Cons – What Makes Clay Tile Challenging in Florida:

1. Extremely brittle: One wrong step from a technician, or even a flying tree branch, can crack tiles. Repairs require precision and specialized tools.
2. Heavy weight requires reinforcement: Most homes need structural upgrades before supporting clay. Without proper reinforcement, the weight can damage the home over time or during a storm.
3. High material and labor costs: Clay tile is among the most expensive roofing options per square foot. The labor required is also specialized and slower than other materials.
4. Difficult to repair or replace: Matching broken tiles can be tough due to color variations, discontinued styles, and manufacturing inconsistencies.

Clay tiles are absolutely worth it if your home can support them and you value long-term curb appeal over low maintenance. But they’re not a set-it-and-forget-it roof. 

Between their fragility, weight, and price, they require a real commitment.

3. Concrete Tiles 

Average cost: $8–$12 / sq ft

Concrete tiles offer the classic look of clay at a more accessible price point. 

They’re thicker, denser, and built to last in storm-prone environments. But while they hold up well under pressure, they come with similar weight concerns and a few unique performance challenges.

Pros – Why Homeowners Choose Concrete Tile:

1. More affordable than clay: Concrete tiles give you the same upscale aesthetic at a lower cost, making them a popular option in mid- to high-end Florida neighborhoods.
2. Excellent insulation value: The density of concrete tiles helps slow down heat transfer, which keeps your attic cooler and reduces HVAC load.
3. Strong storm performance: Properly installed, concrete tiles can resist high winds and flying debris, making them a viable choice in hurricane zones.

Cons – Where Concrete Tiles Fall Short:

1. Heavy and structurally demanding: Like clay, concrete is extremely heavy. Most homes require decking reinforcement to handle the weight safely, which adds cost and complexity.
2. Porous material absorbs moisture: Without sealing, concrete can absorb water, leading to staining, algae growth, or even long-term roof deck damage in humid conditions.
3. Color fading and surface wear: Many concrete tiles are finished with surface color coatings that degrade over time under Florida’s UV exposure, especially in lower-tier products.
4. Cracks under pressure: Though more durable than clay, concrete tiles can still crack under foot or from falling debris, repairs can be costly and labor-intensive.

If your home can support the weight and you’re willing to invest in proper sealing and routine upkeep, concrete tiles can be a reliable and attractive option. 

But if you want something that’s lighter, lower-maintenance, and just as hurricane-ready, there are better options out there.

4. Metal Roofing 

Average cost: $10–$16 / sq ft

If you’re looking for a roof that can take everything Florida throws at it, hurricanes, heat, salt air, and insurance scrutiny, metal roofing stands at the top. 

With a lifespan of 40+ years, industry-leading wind resistance, and energy-saving benefits, it’s the go-to choice for homeowners thinking long-term.

Pros – Why Metal Is a Top Performer in Florida:

1. Extreme wind resistance: Premium systems are engineered to withstand hurricane-force winds up to 165+ mph, making them ideal for storm-prone zones.
2. Outstanding longevity: A properly installed metal roof can last 40–70 years, easily outliving most other materials.
3. Reflects heat, lowers cooling bills: Metal roofs deflect sunlight, keeping attic temps lower and reducing energy costs by up to 30–40%.
4. Lightweight but durable: Unlike tile, metal places minimal stress on your home’s structure, no reinforcement needed in most cases.
5. 5. Solar panel ready: Metal roofs are ideal for solar, no shingles to penetrate, easier mounting, and long-term leak prevention.
6. 6. Eco-conscious and recyclable: Made from recycled materials and fully recyclable at the end of its life, metal is one of the greenest roofing choices out there.

Cons – What to Watch Out For:

1. Higher upfront cost: Metal roofs cost 2–3x more than shingles, though their longevity offsets the initial investment over time.
2. Requires expert installation: Mistakes with flashing, fasteners, or seam sealing can lead to leaks. This is not a DIY or low-bid project.
3. Rust concerns, if you choose the wrong metal: Cheap corrugated steel panels can rust quickly near the coast. Always opt for coastal-grade aluminum or galvalume in salt-air environments.

Metal roofing is one of the most resilient and long-lasting options available for Florida homes. 

While it comes with a higher upfront cost, it offers excellent performance in extreme weather, energy savings, and a long service life. Metal roofing is a smart, forward-thinking investment worth considering.

5. Composite Roofing 

Average cost: $12–$18 / sq ft

Composite delivers high-end aesthetics with the strength and resilience needed to handle Florida’s heat and storms. 

It’s lightweight, durable, and gaining traction as a top-tier option for homeowners who want both style and substance.

Pros – Why Composite Is Gaining Popularity:

1. Wind-rated up to 211 mph: Composite systems like Brava are engineered to outperform in hurricane conditions, exceeding even metal in wind resistance.
2. UV- and moisture-resistant: No cracking, warping, or fading, even after years of exposure to Florida’s relentless sun and salt air.
3. Maintenance-free: Unlike wood or tile, composite doesn’t require staining, sealing, or frequent cleaning. Just clear debris and you’re good to go.
4. Cool-roof certified and energy efficient: Reflective surfaces help reduce heat absorption and lower cooling costs, ideal for tropical climates.
5. Aesthetic flexibility: Composite roofing replicates shake, slate, and barrel tile with stunning realism, without the weight or fragility.
6. Solar-ready: Just like metal, composite systems can easily accommodate solar installations without compromising waterproofing.

Cons – What to Be Aware Of:

1. Premium pricing: Composite materials are priced comparably to high-end tile or metal roofing, making them a bigger initial investment.
2. Limited availability: Not all contractors carry composite products, and even fewer have the training to install them properly.
3. Often overlooked: Because many contractors stick to what they know, that’s why composite is not commonly recommended, even when it’s the better fit.

Composite is tough enough for hurricanes, attractive enough for luxury neighborhoods, and hands-off in terms of maintenance. 

If you want the charm of shake or tile without the constant upkeep, or the risk, composite delivers both form and function.

Specialty Roofs – Silicone, Foam & Flat Roof Systems

Average cost: $6–$12 / sq ft

For homes and buildings with flat or low-slope roofs, especially lanais, modern builds, or commercial spaces, traditional roofing materials like shingles and tile aren’t an option. 

That’s where spray foam and silicone coatings come in. 

These performance-first systems create seamless, waterproof barriers that reflect heat and resist leaks, but they require proper maintenance and skilled installation.

Pros – Why These Systems Make Sense for Flat Roofs:

1. Fully waterproof: Foam and silicone form a seamless, monolithic layer, no seams, no fasteners, no leaks.
2. Highly reflective and energy-saving: These materials bounce off UV rays, reducing attic heat and lowering energy bills, especially important in full-sun zones.
3. Quick to install and recoat: Ideal for re-roofing existing flat systems with minimal disruption. No tear-off needed in many cases.
4. Lightweight with no structural upgrades required: Unlike tile or metal, foam and silicone add almost no load to your home.
5. Compatible with solar: Solar panels can be mounted directly onto foam systems without penetrating the roof deck, reducing leak risk.

Cons – Where These Roofs Require Extra Attention:

1. Routine re-coating required: Foam and silicone roofs need to be re-coated every 7–10 years to stay watertight and effective.
2. Not DIY-friendly: Application requires special equipment, trained installers, and specific weather conditions for success.
3. Limited aesthetics: These roofs aren’t designed for looks. They’re functional, not decorative, and may not meet visual expectations for residential front elevations.
4. Potential insurance hurdles: Some insurance carriers ask for additional inspections or installation documentation before approving or renewing coverage.

If you have a flat or low-slope roof, silicone or foam systems are among the best waterproofing solutions available in Florida. 

They’re fast, effective, and energy efficient, but they’re only as good as the team that installs and maintains them.

Helpful Resource → How Often Does A Roof Need To Be Replaced In Florida

How to Actually Choose the Right Roof for You?

The truth is that there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Here are some factors that can help you determine the right roofing option for your home:

1. Long-Term Homeowners Need Long-Term Materials

If this is your forever home, or even your 10-year plan, you need a roof that lasts and doesn’t nickel-and-dime you with repairs. 

Metal and composite cost more up front, but they’ll pay you back in performance, comfort, and peace of mind.

Selling soon? A composite or tile roof adds serious curb appeal and buyer confidence, especially in competitive markets like Naples or Fort Myers.

2. Resale Value Is Stronger With Durable Roofing

Florida buyers are wary of aging roofs. 

Shingles over 10 years old can kill a deal or delay financing. A newer, storm-resistant roof, especially metal or composite, can speed up the sale and raise your asking price.

3. High-Wind and Coastal Zones Demand Real Protection

If you’re near the coast or in a wind-prone zone, treat your roof like your first line of defense.

• Metal roofs are wind-rated to 165+ mph
• Composite systems like Brava go even higher, up to 211 mph
• Clay or concrete tile can work, but only with proper structural reinforcement

Bottom line: don’t cut corners where storms are concerned.

4. Planning for Solar? Choose Smart Compatibility

If solar is in your future, start planning now. Metal is the best match, no shingles to disrupt, and panels mount cleanly without leaks. 

Composite works well too, but make sure your roofer knows how to prep the system properly.

5. HOA Restrictions Can Be Worked Around

Yes, you can still get the roof you want, even in an HOA. 

Many still cling to outdated rules, but most boards will approve modern metal or composite once they see the product samples and documentation.

We’ve helped dozens of homeowners get HOA signoff, and if needed, we’ll work directly with your HOA so you don’t have to fight that battle alone.

Bottom line: Choosing the right roof is about fit. Your goals. Your home. Your future. Now you have a list to choose from but also have a look at materials to run away from.

Materials to Avoid Unless You’re Desperate

Sometimes budgets are tight or the clock’s ticking before a sale, but cutting corners on a roof in Florida can cost you far more in the long run. Here are the roof options to avoid unless they are the only possibility.

1. Low-End Asphalt Shingles (No Wind Rating)

• Cheapest upfront—but most expensive after the first storm
• No wind certification = high risk of tear-off
• Often installed with low-grade nails and underlayment
• Most insurers won’t cover them past 10–15 years

If shingles are your only option, insist on architectural-grade with wind certification and documentation.

2. Uncoated Corrugated Metal

• Rusts quickly in coastal air
• Causes staining, clogged gutters, and rot
• Hated by insurers if not sealed properly
• Fails fast without protective coatings

Want metal? Go with coastal-grade aluminum or galvalume. 

3. DIY or Unlicensed Installations

• Misaligned panels, improper fasteners, and zero sealed decking
• Fails inspection, voids warranties, and denies insurance claims
• Florida’s codes aren’t optional—they’re survival

Roofing codes in Florida exist for a reason. 

Using a licensed professional helps ensure your roof is built to standard and gives you the documentation you may need for insurance or resale later on.

Bottom line: If the choice is between a cheap roof now and waiting for financing, wait. We offer financing for a reason. 

We’d rather help you bridge the gap and install something that’ll actually protect your home. Because when the storm hits, shortcuts aren’t just expensive—they’re dangerous.

Helpful Resource → Roof Replacement Cost Florida | By Location, Material & Scenario

Wrapping Up – Choose the Roof That Works for You

The right material depends on your home, your goals, and how long you plan to stay. Whether you’re battling coastal winds, planning for solar, or navigating HOA rules, there’s a solution that fits.

At Florida Roofing and Gutters, we don’t sell roofs, we build long-term confidence. 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by @floridaroofingandgutters

From inspections to installation, we’re here to help you choose a roof that lasts through hurricanes, heat, and everything in between.

Need clarity or a second opinion? Let’s talk. 

We’ve reroofed hundreds of Florida homes, and we know what works and what doesn’t. We’re ready to use all that experience to deliver the best to you!