Are Metal Roofs Cheaper Than Shingles in Florida?
Jan 12, 2026
When you’re wondering, “Are metal roofs cheaper than shingles? “, the easy answer is, not initially, but maybe when all is said and done. At Florida Roofing and Gutters, we make it our point to separate fact from fiction: yes, metal is more expensive in the short-term, but for many Southern homeowners, those long-term benefits (the savings) can quickly make up the difference.
Key Takeaways
- Metal roofs are not cheaper upfront than asphalt shingles, but they often cost less over time.
- Shingle roofs have a lower initial installation cost, making them more budget-friendly in the short term.
- Metal roofs last significantly longer and require less maintenance, reducing lifetime expenses.
- In Florida’s climate, metal roofing can lower energy bills due to its reflective properties.
- Florida Roofing and Gutters helps homeowners compare metal and shingle roofing options to find the best value for their budget and long-term goals.
Shingles in general are cheaper upfront (especially the asphalt variety). But with metal roofing also come perks, such as cooling costs, labor savings, and fewer replacements, which often balance the total-cost-of-ownership challenge in favor of metal. This article guides you through the specifics and tells you what they are, gives you real numbers, and explains how to determine if going that route might make sense for your home in Florida.
Book Your FREE Inspection Today!
Upfront Costs: Metal vs Shingles
Let’s get straight to it: roofs made of metal are generally more expensive than those made of asphalt shingles at the outset.
Period: Asphalt shingles start at $3 to $5 per square foot installed.
Metal roofs, of varying types (steel, aluminum, standing seam) typically range between $8 to $14 per square foot or more.
Those figures can vary greatly depending on the complexity of your roof (like the pitch, levels, penetrations, and walkability) and where you live (inspection costs, labor rates, and local material prices). If you have a simple roof, and local labor is competitive, the premium can be lower — but there will still be a premium.
So, are metal roofs less expensive than shingles? — not if you’re looking at first-dollar cost only.
Why Homeowners Continue to Go Metal
Because cost isn’t everything. Here’s what makes metal appealing:
Longer Life And Fewer Replacements
Most metal roofing lasts between 40 and 70 years (although some will last even longer)
On the other hand, asphalt shingles here in Florida can easily live up to 15–30 years with our issues of sun, heat, storms, and humidity.
Writ large, that means that many homeowners will have to replace shingles 2 or three times in the same time during which they install a metal roof. Every replacement involves labor, waste, tear-off, and disruption.
Saving You Energy And Reflecting Away Heat From The Sun
Metal roofs reflect much of the solar heat, keeping homes cooler in hot climates such as Florida.
Shingles can absorb heat, which may lead to a hotter attic and greater AC needs. Those additional cooling bills over the years can add up.
Better Performance Against The Weather
Florida requires a roof that can stand up to wind, storms, and torrential rain. Metal roofs (specifically standing seam) are usually tested against strong uplift winds, including 165+ mph in high-end installations.
Shingles, on the other hand, can be more easily raised and lose granules or fail under severe weather.
Lower Maintenance
Metal roofs might need inspections, periodic recoating or sealing and cleaning — but rarely do they require full-scale repair.
Shingles, on the other hand, frequently require spot repairs to fix leaks, replace shingles, and address granule loss, algae growth, or curling.
Resale, Insurance, And Value
With a life span and long-term cost savings in mind, an appropriately installed metal roof can add resale value to a home and may even offer insurance discounts (depending on insurer policy) in some regions.
Plus, when you combine all those benefits, the lifetime cost of metal can compete — or even outperform — shingles over many decades for many homeowners.
How to Decide Which Is “Cheaper” for You
Here’s how to figure out which is the better option for your property:
Calculate the total life cost of your roof
Take into account years of service, replacement ratio, history of reconditioning, and energy reduction.
(A simple sample: If a shingle roof has a life span of 20 years, you need to replace it twice over 60 years; metal roofing might have just one replacement layer in the same period.)
Get Detailed Bids From Experts
You want apples-to-apples comparisons: same underlayment, same flashing, same structural prep. A pro like Florida Roofing and Gutters can provide that.
Consider Your Time Horizon
If you plan to stay in the home 30+ years, metal starts looking better. If you think you’ll be moving in 5–10 years, the lower installation cost of shingles might be more reasonable.
Add Climate And Storm Risk
If your area is regularly affected by hurricanes, high temperatures, or other extreme weather conditions, the durability premium for metal may justify itself more quickly.
Look Into Local Incentives, Building Codes, And Insurance Policy Information
Some areas or insurance companies may also offer credits for certain high-wind-rated roofing. Local building codes may err on the side of caution, opting for better materials.
Book Your FREE Inspection Today!
Common Misconceptions & Pitfalls
Myth: “Metal will always be twice as expensive.”
Reality: In basic, straight-forward or smaller installations, the cost of premium metal could be 50%-100% more than aluminum or corrugated metal.
Myth: “A Metal roof is louder in the rain.”
Reality: If installed with reasonable insulation and underlayment, noise is virtually undetectable.
Myth: “Once you put metal in, you’re never going to look at it again!”
Reality: Periodically check flashing, fasteners, and coatings. But major work is infrequent.
Pitfall: Quality of materials and installation at fault
A poor installation of metal is worse than a good shingle job. And always, insist on certified installers, proper flashing, and warranties.
So, Are Metal Roofs More Affordable Than Shingles?
Let’s revisit the original question. “are metal roofs cheaper than shingles?” It all depends on what is cheaper:
If by “cheaper” you mean cheaper up front, no, shingles will be less expensive on a dollar per square foot basis.
If you consider that impact over 30–50+ years, including replacements, repairs, and energy (not to mention pure resilience), yes, metal roofs often win in total value.
In other words, Metal roofs don’t cost less to buy, but they can cost less in the end.
Selection of Providers: Why it is Important
Here is where Florida Roofing and Gutters steps in. You can get quotes for raw material yourself, but the result is expertise. Here’s what we bring:
- Florida seasoned weather, code, and material experience
- Access to exclusive metal systems premium
- Certified crew work
- A commitment to value, not just the sale
The installation of a roof system is a multi-thousand-dollar job, and if you’re looking for one that will last decades, deliver energy savings, and resilience in the face of Mother Nature, well then, you deserve an installer who knows what’s at stake. DIY or discount crews can save money now — but pay for it in headaches later.
Conclusion
In the short term, metal roofs are more expensive than shingles.
When you consider the super-long lifespan of metal, metal often comes out on top regarding combined value.
The precise break-even point will depend on your roof, the climate, and your time frame.
If you’re weighing your options and want expert guidance, Florida Roofing and Gutters is here to help. Serving homeowners throughout Southwest Florida, they offer high-quality metal and shingle roofing solutions, honest recommendations, and professional installation you can trust.
Ready to choose the right roof for your home and budget? Contact Florida Roofing and Gutters today to schedule your consultation.
Book Your FREE Inspection Today!
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Are metal roofs cheaper than shingles upfront?
No. Asphalt shingles are usually less expensive initially, while metal roofs have a higher installation cost due to material quality and labor requirements.
2. Which roof is cheaper over the long term?
Metal roofs are often cheaper long-term because they last 40–70 years and require fewer repairs, while shingle roofs may need replacement every 15–25 years.
3. Why do metal roofs cost more initially?
Metal roofing materials are more durable, energy-efficient, and engineered to withstand harsh weather, which increases upfront costs.
4. Do metal roofs help lower energy costs?
Yes. Metal roofs reflect solar heat, helping reduce cooling costs—especially beneficial in hot, sunny climates like Southwest Florida.
5. Who can help me choose between metal and shingle roofing in Southwest Florida?
Florida Roofing and Gutters offers expert consultations, high-quality materials, and professional installation services across Venice, Sarasota, Naples, and Fort Myers, helping you make the most cost-effective choice for your home.
